Open in App
Log In Start studying!

Select your language

Suggested languages for you:

Let \(B\) be any language over the alphabet \(\Sigma\). Prove that \(B=B^{+}\)iff $B B \subseteq B$.

Short Answer

Expert verified
In summary, to prove that a language B is equal to its concatenation closure, B^+, if and only if the concatenation of B with itself (BB) is a subset of B, we demonstrated two directions of the equivalence: 1. Assuming B = B^+, we showed that BB ⊆ B, as B^+ contains all concatenations of any length of words from B, including BB. 2. Assuming BB ⊆ B, we showed that B = B^+, because B ⊆ B^+ and B^+ ⊆ B (since B contains all elements from B^n where n goes from 1 to infinity). Hence, we have proved the equivalence: B = B^+ ⟺ BB ⊆ B.
See the step by step solution

Step by step solution

Unlock all solutions

Get unlimited access to millions of textbook solutions with Vaia Premium

Over 22 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with Vaia!

Step 1: Assuming B = B^+

To prove that BB ⊆ B if B = B^+, let's first analyze what it means for a language B to be equal to its concatenation closure B^+. By definition, the concatenation closure is the smallest superset of B that includes concatenations of any length of words from B. Formally, \(B^+ = \bigcup_{n=1}^{\infty} B^n\), where each B^n is the n-fold concatenation of the language B with itself, and B^1 = B. Since B = B^+, it contains all concatenations of any length of words from B. Therefore, the concatenation of B with itself, denoted as BB or B^2, must also be a part of B. In other words, BB ⊆ B.

Step 2: Assuming BB ⊆ B

To prove that B = B^+ if BB ⊆ B, let's analyze what it means for BB to be a subset of B. By definition, every element (word) within BB must also be an element of B. Since BB ⊆ B, we know that every element in B^2 (the concatenation of B with itself) is also in B. Now, let's consider the concatenation closure B^+ again. We know that \(B^+ = \bigcup_{n=1}^{\infty} B^n\) and that B^1 = B. It's clear that B ⊆ B^+ because B^+ includes all concatenations of any length of words from B. Since we've shown that BB = B^2 ⊆ B, and B ⊆ B^+, we can now confidently state that B = B^+. Specifically, B ⊆ B^+ and B^+ ⊆ B (since B contains all elements from B^n where n goes from 1 to infinity). Thus, we have shown that if BB ⊆ B, then B = B^+. By demonstrating both directions (B = B^+ implies BB ⊆ B, and BB ⊆ B implies B = B^+), we have proved the given equivalence: B = B^+ ⟺ BB ⊆ B.

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Access millions of textbook solutions in one place

  • Access over 3 million high quality textbook solutions
  • Access our popular flashcard, quiz, mock-exam and notes features
  • Access our smart AI features to upgrade your learning
Get Vaia Premium now
Access millions of textbook solutions in one place

Most popular questions from this chapter

Chapter 1

Prove that every NFA can be converted to an equivalent one that has a single accept state.

Chapter 1

Each of the following languages is the intersection of two simpler languages. In each part, construct DFAs for the simpler languages, then combine them using the construction discussed in footnote 3 (page 46) to give the state diagram of a DFA for the language given. In all parts, $\Sigma=\\{\mathrm{a}, \mathrm{b}\\} .$ a. \(\\{w \mid w\) has at least three a's and at least two b's \({ }^{\text {A }} \mathbf{b} .\\{w \mid w\) has exactly two a's and at least two b's \(\\}\) c. \(\\{w \mid w\) has an even number of a's and one or two b's \(\\}\) A. \(\\{w \mid w\) has an even number of a's and each a is followed by at least one b \(\\}\) e. \(\\{w \mid w\) starts with an a and has at most one b \(\\}\) f. \(\\{w \mid w\) has an odd number of a's and ends with a b \(\\}\) g. \(\\{w \mid w\) has even length and an odd number of a's \(\\}\)

Chapter 1

Prove that for each \(n>0\), a language \(B_{n}\) exists where a. \(B_{n}\) is recognizable by an NFA that has \(n\) states, and b. if \(B_{n}=A_{1} \cup \cdots \cup A_{k}\), for regular languages \(A_{i}\), then at least one of the \(A_{i}\) requires a DFA with exponentially many states.

Chapter 1

Let \(N\) be an NFA with \(k\) states that recognizes some language \(A\). a. Show that if \(A\) is nonempty, \(A\) contains some string of length at most \(k\). b. Show, by giving an example, that part (a) is not necessarily true if you replace both \(A\) 's by \(\bar{A}\). c. Show that if \(\bar{A}\) is nonempty, \(\bar{A}\) contains some string of length at most \(2^{k}\). d. Show that the bound given in part (c) is nearly tight; that is, for each \(k\), demonstrate an NFA recognizing a language \(A_{k}\) where \(\overline{A_{k}}\) is nonempty and where \(\overline{A_{k}}\) 's shortest member strings are of length exponential in \(k\). Come as close to the bound in (c) as you can.

Chapter 1

Consider the language $F=\left\\{\mathrm{a}^{i} \mathrm{~b}^{j} \mathrm{c}^{k} \mid i, j, k \geq 0\right.\( and if \)i=1\( then \)\left.j=k\right\\} .$ a. Show that \(F\) is not regular. b. Show that \(F\) acts like a regular language in the pumping lemma. In other words, give a pumping length \(p\) and demonstrate that \(F\) satisfies the three conditions of the pumping lemma for this value of \(p\). c. Explain why parts (a) and (b) do not contradict the pumping lemma.

Join over 22 million students in learning with our Vaia App

The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place.

  • Flashcards & Quizzes
  • AI Study Assistant
  • Smart Note-Taking
  • Mock-Exams
  • Study Planner
Join over 22 million students in learning with our Vaia App Join over 22 million students in learning with our Vaia App

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks