Americas
Europe
Problem 12
Give two reasons why the dual-pricing system of transfer pricing is not widely used.
What do you think about this solution?
We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.
\((\mathrm{CMA}, \text { adapted). }\) Quest Motors, Inc., operates as a decentralized multidivision company. The Vivo division of Quest Motors purchases most of its airbags from the airbag division. The airbag division's incremental cost for manufacturing the airbags is 90 dollarper unit. The airbag division is currently working at \(80 \%\) of capacity. The current market price of the airbags is 125 dollar per unit. 1\. Using the general guideline presented in the chapter, what is the minimum price at which the airbag division would sell airbags to the Vivo division? 2\. Suppose that Quest Motors requires that whenever divisions with unused capacity sell products internally, they must do so at the incremental cost. Evaluate this transfer-pricing policy using the criteria of goal congruence, evaluating division performance, motivating management effort, and preserving division autonomy. 3\. If the two divisions were to negotiate a transfer price, what is the range of possible transfer prices? Evaluate this negotiated transfer-pricing policy using the criteria of goal congruence, evaluating division performance, motivating management effort, and preserving division autonomy. 4\. Instead of allowing negotiation, suppose that Quest specifies a hybrid transfer price that "splits the difference" between the minimum and maximum prices from the divisions' standpoint. What would be the resulting transfer price for airbags?
Host Hotels, a small chain of business hotels in the Mid- Atlantic region, is interested in gaining access to the boutique lodging market by acquiring a hotel group in that sector. Host Hotels intends to operate the newly acquired hotels independently from the rest of its chain, while pursuing other boutique market opportunities in other cities. One of the prospects is Bennington Properties, a group of 10 historic hotels in Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Washington. All hotels in the group include the name "Bennington," as in Mainline Bennington, Georgetown Bennington, etc. Buying for all 20 hotels is done by the company's central office. Hotel managers must follow strict guidelines for all aspects of hotel management in an attempt to maintain consistency across locations. Hotel managers are evaluated on the basis of achieving profit goals developed by the central office. The other prospect is Eastern Innkeepers, a group of 25 spa retreats, bed and breakfasts, and countrin inns in rural Virginia and North Carolina. Each property in the group was previously an independently owned company. Many of the previous owners are now employed as individual property managers. These manag. ers are given significant flexibility in decision making, allowing them to negotiate purchases with suppliers and develop property marketing plans. Managers are rewarded for exceeding self-developed return-on investment goalswith company stock options. Some managers have become significant shareholders in the company, and some managers have even recommended decisions to acquire additional real estate. However, the increased autonomy has led to compettition and price cutting among Eastern Innkeepers properties wittin the same geographic market, resulting in lower margins. 1\. Would you describe Bennington Properties as having a centralized or a decentralized structure? Explain. 2\. Would you describe Eastern Innkeepers as having a centralized or a decentralized structure? Discuss some of the benefits and costs of that type of structure. 3\. Would hotels in each chain be considered cost centers, revenue centers, profit centers, or investment centers? How does that tie into the evaluation of property managers? 4\. Assume that Host Hotels chooses to acquire Eastern Innkeepers. What steps can the management of Host Hotels take to improve goal congruence between property managers and the larger company?
Ballantine Corp. produces and sells lead crystal glassware. The firm consists of two divisions, Commercial and Specialty. The Commercial division manufactures 300,000 glasses per year. It incurs variable manufacturing costs of 8 dollar per unit and annual fixed manufacturing costs of 900,000 dollar. The Commercial division sells 100,000 units externally at a price of 12 dollar each, mostly to department stores. It transfers the remaining 200,000 units internally to the Specialty division, which modifies the units, adds an etched design, and sells them directly to consumers online. Ballantine Corp. has adopted a market-based transfer-pricing policy. For each glass it receives from the Commercial division, the Specialty division pays the weighted-average external price the Commercial division charges its customers outside the company. The current transfer price is accordingly set at 12 dollar. Eileen McCarthy, the manager of the Commercial division, receives an offer from Home Décor, a chain of upscale home furnishings stores. Home Décor offers to buy 20,000 glasses at a price of 9 dollar each, knowing that the entire lead crystal industry (including Ballantine Corp.) has excess capacity at this time. The variable manufacturing cost to the Commercial division for the units Home Décor is requesting is 8 dollar, and there are no additional costs associated with this offer. Accepting Home Décor's offer would not affect the current price of 12 dollar charged to existing external customers. 1\. Calculate the Commercial division's current annual level of profit (without the new order). 2\. Compute the change in the Commercial division's profit if it accepts Home Décor's offer. Will Eileen McCarthy accept this offer if her aim is to maximize the Commercial division's profit? 3\. Would the top management of Ballantine Corp. want the Commercial division to accept the offer? Compute the change in firm-wide profit associated with Home Décor's offer.
"Cost and price information play no role in negotiated transfer prices." Do you agree? Explain.
Quick Stop operates 1,000 convenience stores throughout the United States. The company's slogan is "Best Stop of the Day," and its mission is to make every customer a return customer. Ouick Stop's corporate strategy supports this mission by stressing the importance of sparkling clean surroundings, well- stocked shelves, and, above all, cheerful employees. \(0 f\) course, improved shareholder value drives this strategy. 1\. Assume that Quick Stop uses a balanced scorecard approach (see Chapter 12) to formulating its management control system. List three measures that Quick Stop might use to evaluate each of the four balanced scorecard perspectives: financial perspective, customer perspective, internal-business-process perspective, and learning-and-growth perspective. 2\. How would the management controls related to financial and customer perspectives at Quick Stop differ between the following three employees: a store manager, a regional sales manager, and the corporation's CE0?
The first learning app that truly has everything you need to ace your exams in one place.